Tri-Counties Genealogy & History by Joyce M. Tice
Cemetery Section
Tioga County, Pennsylvania
Bradford County PA
Chemung County NY
Tioga County PA
 Home How to Use  Disclaimer Copyright More Cemeteries Deerfield Township Joyce New & Search
Butler Hill Cemetery,  Deerfield Township,  Tioga County, Pennsylvania - 1972
Joyce's Search Tip - December 2007 -
Do You Know that you can search just the 600 pages of Tioga County Cemetery Records on the site by using the Cemeteries -Tioga button in the Partitioned search engine at the bottom of the Current What's New Page? If you use that partition follow these steps to search just one cemetery
1. Choose Cemeteries - Tioga. 
2. Enter part of the cemetery name [ie Newbury or Furman] AND a surname. 
3. Choose the Find ALL Words option. Then it will find just the pages with that surname in the one cemetery you indicated. 

BUTLER  HILL CEMETERY

DEERFIELD TOWNSHIP TIOGA COUNTY, PA.

The following list is part of the Tioga County Cemetery Inscriptions– Volume 3.  Copied by Rhoda ENGLISH Ladd and Lola WETHERBEE Franke August 2, 1972.   Reprinted with permsission of Rhoda ENGLISH Ladd.

The second largest cemetery in Deerfield is incorporated as the Highland Cemetery Association and the cemetery is known as the Butler Hill Cemetery. It is located opposite the Baptist Church on Butler Hill. Wanting to have a burial ground in East Chatham, as this area was called, a meeting was held Sept. 14, 1869 at the home of Rev. Selden Butler for the purpose of making arrangements for the purchase of a lot from Elihu Bowen and Selden Butler. It is located on Road 58028.


 
Butler Hill Cemetery 2010   Butler Hill Cemetery Obituaries
Sutton Richard 1855 1924 Father
Sutton Lola May July 6, 1863 Dec. 24, 1901 Mother
Thompson Hulda Mar. 28 1886 age 1 y, 6m. "Little Hulda" d/of L.& J. Thompson.
Sutton Isaac Mar. 9, 1824 Feb. 13, 1906
Sutton Hulda Oct 10, 1821 Nov. 20, 1890 w/of Isaac
Kemp Betsey A. 1860 1946
VanDusen Herbert 1864 1916
VanDusen Adell 1865 1941 w/of Herbert
VanDusen D.L. May 26, 1833 July 24, 1901 Civ. War marker & flag
VanDusen Julia 1841 1921 w/of D.L.
VanDusen Bennie Feb. 17, 1872 Atr. 4, 1881 s/of D.L. & Julia M.
VanDusen Eva Mar. 16, 1863 Mar. 18, 1881 d/of D.L. & Julia
Daniels Ben. B. 1881 1959
Daniels Blanche S. 1883 1947
Daniels Melissa 1839 1899
Daniels Henry F. 1817 1899 Father
Daniels Esther G. 1816 1900 Mother
Daniels H.F. 1817 1899 Civ. War Flag & marker
Daniels Jerusha Lee 1845 1912 w/of H.F.
Daniels Ned J. 1867 1941
Daniels Fred F. 1867 1889
Daniels George H. 1886 1969
Day Abram May 22, 1825 Jan. 8, 1899
Day Mary J. Aug. 19, 1835 No Date w/of Abram
Day Martha J. June 19, 1834 Jan. 14, 1899 w/of T.Z.
Day Bennie O. July 3, 1882 July 21, 1884 (see below - on a separate stone)
Day Bennie O. July 3, 1882 July 21, 1884 s/of Z.T. & M.J. - appears on the same as the T.Z.
Day Fred G. 1884 1952
Wells Anita Marie 1913 1964 In memory by Ben Greene
Carl William A. 1884 1948
Carl Laura A. 1889 19** ** Uncut
Finnerty Richard F. 1942 1965 Served armed forces from 1941-1945
Westmiller W.H. 1855 1958
Westmiller Margaret  1866 1942
Westmiller Guy 1887 1958
Westmiller Mary 1888 1968
* *Unmarked Grave here
Stanley Harry M. 1890 1950
Stanley Sylvester H. 1860 1935
Stanley Eliza T. 1864 1935
Stanley Hubert Lee 1894 1971
Brown Merle F. 1903 19** (** uncut??)
Brown Lena S. 1900 1966
Carl Edgar 1866 1937 Father
Carl Lolie 1866 1918 Mother
Carl Emmet W. 1889 1968
Carl Charlotte E. 1896 19** (** uncut??)
Carl Everett 1926 1944 s/of E.W. & C.E.
Brown Richard Gene Jan. 25, 1938 Jan. 28, 1938 s/of Eldon & Rita 
Seely Henry Morris Aug. 22, 1836 Mar. 28, 1911 Father
Seely Emily E. Apr. 24, 1831 6/1/03 Mother w/of Henry
Seely George B. July 4, 1870 Apr. 16, 1907 s/of H.M & E.E.
Seely Mary B. July 26, 1872 aged 12-3-1 d/of H.M & E.E.
Seely J.D. 1864 1917
Seely - Lg. Stone no graves
Wheaton Silas B. Feb. 28, 1849 5/18/11 Father
Butler Laura **Wheaton 1859 1941 Mother *NOTE: Laura's nee is ALLEN- m.1st. Wheaton 2nd. Butler - Ref. Judy Allen Cwiklinski
Wheaton Ellen 1851 1888 d/of J.M. & Sylvia
Wheaton Luther Oct. 15, 1847 May 27, 1870 Co.F, 4th Reg. Maine Vol. Civ War flag
Wheaton John M. Mar. 30, 1824 Feb. 26, 1901 Father
Wheaton Sylvia Nov. 5, 1824 Sept. 11, 1897 Mother
Barr Mina Feb. 19, 1857 Nov. 13, 1897 Mother -- w/of Nathan
Barr Nathan 1851 19** ** un-cut
Barr Ellen 1855 19** ** un-cut
Flat stone on ground----Unreadable
Chamberlain Etta June 29, 1867 Mar. 31, 1897 w/of G.W.
Satterly Samuel D. 1838 1911 Co. E. 42 Reg. Pa. Vol. Flag
Satterly Delilah 1838 1911 w/S.D. dates-sic - JKC - as written
Taylor Winslow 1812 1885 Father
Taylor Margaret 1832 1914 w/of Winslow
Taylor May. June 10, 1869 Oct. 16, 1849 d/of Mr & Mrs. Winslow Taylor
Dewey Hiram 1848 1918 Father
Dewey Ida 1858 1918 Mother
Dimmick Walter S. June 4, 1870 May. 3, 1944
Dimmick Maggie A. Mar. 3, 1879 Aug. 29, 1953
"RICE on front of Family Stone
SEELY on back, with individual stones" the below indiv.
*Ernest D. 1882 1953
*Phebe A. 1880 1937
*Grace 1904 **** **** Uncut
Smith *Ethel G. Rice 1908 **** **** Uncut
Seely James H. 1844 1919 Co. H., 207th Pa., Vol. Civ. War
Seely Annah E. 1849 1932 w/of James H.
Mack Minnie B. 1871 1918
Odle Hattie Apr. 27, 1858 June 22, 1899 w/of A.S.
Odle Hattie Stone - no dates
Odle Gerald Stone - no dates
Odle Fred Stone - no dates
Odle Eula Dec. 22, 1888 Mar. 11, 1912 d/of A.S. & H.E.
Bosard Ann E. Apr. 5, 1837 July 17, 1882
** Graves here no markers
Seamans Israel Feb. 20, 1826 7/13/08 Father
Seamans Emma Jane Jan. 5, 1834 Dec. 31, 1900 w/of Israel
Seamans George B. 1858 1923
Seamans Ida F. 1863 1934 w/of George B.
Seamans Clair E. 1915 1965
Seamans June L. 1916 19** ** uncut??
** ** Footstone - E.W.
Kizer Adelia July 12, 1856 June 29, 1899 w/of S.D. Kizer
Kizer Seldon D. 1853 1936
Kizer Mortimer J. 1892 1919
** ** more graves on Kizer plot but no markers.
Bowen Elihu Mar. 14, 1819 Feb. 14, 1896
Bowen Eliza A. Sept. 15, 1824 Nov. 5, 1897
Bowen Lena July 26, 1859 Sept. 5, 1881 d/of Elihu & Eliza
Wheaton Elmer H. 1851 1923 Father
Wheaton Eva J. 1854 1887 w/of E.H. 
Wheaton Raymond Jan. 31, 1880 Jan. 9, 1902 s/of E.H. & E.J.
Wheaton Alma Nov. 7, 1884 Apr. 4, 1902 d/of E.H. & E.J.
Weeks Alma May 23, 1813 Mar. 11, 1890
Doan Floyd W. 1874 1914 Lodge emblem & #324 -Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen. Lg. Family Stone.
Stafford Fred W. 1896 1969
Stafford Hazel C. 1894 19** ** - uncut???
Carl E. Wayne 1914 19** ** - uncut???
Carl Winifred S. 1915 19** ** - uncut???
Edwards Leo H. 1884 1946 Edwards family all on a Lg. stone tog.
Edwards Stella C. 1887 1955
Edwards Basil 5/23/09 Aug. 18, 1909 s/of L.H. & E
Edwards Gertie 1875 1908 s/of H.G. & Mary
** **Several Graves - No markers
Bloom William Jan. 62, 1839 Oct. 31, 1904 Father -- Co. D. 136th P.U.
Bloom Sarah M. Aug. 1, 1842 Dec. 14, 1908 w/of William
Brown Alfred E. 1876 19** ** Uncut???
Brown Anna S. 1879 1947
Campbell R.W. Aug. 20, 1830 * *No date - Co. H. 207 Pa. Vol. Civ War
Campbell Jane L. May 9, 1849 Nov. 19, 1911 w/of R.W.
Kizer Nicholas * *No dates - Co. A. 149 Pa. Inf. Civ War
** **Footstone for J. K.
Kizer Henry 1843 1919 Father - Co. H. Pa. Vol. Civ. War
Kizer Lucy J. Aug. 23, 1848 Feb. 11, 1904
Kizer Fved 1869 1926 Brother
Kizer Ned J. 1877 1943 M.W.A. Emblem & Axe
Kizer Martha E. 1881 1941
Kizer W.W. Oct. 15, 1844 Aug. 26, 1902 Father
Grover Jane Oct. 4, 1845 ** ** uncut w/of W.W.
Odle Abram Nov. 19, 1873 Feb. 2, 1904
Odle Lucretia B. 1871 1956 w/of Abram
Odle Herbert F. 1879 1944
Odle DeFrance 1854 1900 Father
Odle Ella E. 1854 1919 Mother
Odle Dora M. 1881 1965
Upham Viola July 4, 1853 Dec. 7, 1889 w/of William- also a footstone w/ V.U.
Baird Enora June 15, 1874 Apr. 30, 1901 w/of W.A. Baird
Baird Elwin 5/5/01 Age 8mo-28d s/of W.A. & E. Baird
Baird William A. 1868 1937
Baird Francis 1866 1924 w/of W.A. Baird
Croft M.A. Feb. 26, 1841 Dec. 27, 1891 Co. A. 149 Pa. Vol. Civ. War
Croft Gertrude Oct. 4, 1857 Dec. 25, 1889 w/of M.A.
Croft John S. June 8, 1847 Aug. 30, 1908 Father
Croft Maria C. May 19, 1861 6/17/45 Mother
Odle Minnie May 2, 1856 Feb. 3, 1884
Foley Allen D. 1900 * Uncut
Foley Ruth R. 1903 * Uncut
Sears Theodore 1882 1884 child of Jas. D. & Mary V. Sears
Sears Edith May 1885 1885 child of Jas. D. & Mary V. Sears
Sears Ida M. 1893 1894 child of Jas. D. & Mary V. Sears
Kizer James  June 18, 1881 66 yr & 7 mo Co. L. 2nd Pa. Cav.
Kizer Martha M. Sept. 15, 1891 aged 70 w/of James
Kizer Joel 1846 1924 Co. L. 2nd. Pa. Cav.
Kizer Caroline 1848 1924 w/of Joel
Horton Floyd L. 1879 1939
Horton Nellie K. 1873 1956
Gardner Almon T. Dec. 18, 18** age 32 **Stone broken - year of death unknown
Yentzer Marion 1901 1967 Kenyon Funeral Home marker.
Seely Charles 1843 1915
Seely Kattie 1877 1884 d/of Chas. & Sarah
Johnson O.J. Sept. 9, 1835 * *Uncut? - 207 Co. H. Pa. Vol.
Johnson Melissa  June 30, 1835 Oct. 26, 1890 w/of O.J.
Johnson Clara Sept. 10, 1868 Apr. 3, 1892 d/of O.G. & M.J.
Johnson Orange 1842 1923 Father - 207 Pa. Vol. Civ. War
Curran Lias M. Feb. 4, 1877 45-6-15
* * - Stone with Curran broke -- wife?
Teachman Frank C. 1858 1899
Teachman Frances C. 1861 1947
Harrington Frank 1873 1947
Cole Jesse 1880 1954
Cole Lurie *1844 1944 *Should y.o.b be 1884? -- sic.
Cole John Apr. 6, 1887 Dec. 25, 1955 PA. Cook - 31 Field Art. WW I
Seely Frank Apr. 15, 1854 Age 4mo & 3d s/of J.B. & H.
Seely Eddy Dec. 20, 1856 Aged 3 mo. s/of Jonas B. & Hannah
Seely Jonas B. Mar. 17, 1810 Dec. 29, 1888
Seely Hannah Nov. 25, 1815 May 29, 1898
Tyler Harry Apr. 20, 1840 Jan. 26, 1899
Tyler Romyette Olds Dec. 5, 1841 Oct. 1, 1906 Nee: Olds
Tyler Erwin May 24, 1873 3-3-12 ch of Harry Jr. & Romyette Tyler
Tyler Oscar May 6, 1873 4-6-4 ch of Harry Jr. & Romyette Tyler
Stanley Homer D. 1892 1894 s/of Sylvester & Eliza
Gates Adaline O. Apr. 4, 1888 53-1-12
Gates Letty * 3yrs & 14 days * No date entered - "Our little Letty"
Gates Merton L. 1871 1928
Roberts Lena Gates 1884 1967 Nee: Gates
Smith Carrie 1891 19** ** Uncut?
Church Daniel Aug. 9, 1874 64-11-12
Church Hannah Aug. 9, 1811 June 11, 1885
Church Daniel Apr. 8, 1864 24 & 11 mo. "Died while in defense of his country." s/of Daniel & Hannah
Church Theophilus May 16, 1862 30 & 29 days
Church Addilaide 1844 1928
Church Newbury 1847 1925
Church Theodore 1831 1915
Church Ester J. 1833 1898 w/of T. Church
Clark Mary Jan. 13, 1872 June 10, 1894
Church Francis M. Mar. 13, 1882 43-3-14 G.A.R. Civ. War holder - but no service record
Church F. Lee 1880 1954
Miles Mary July 24, 1869 Feb. 19, 1895 w/of C.M. Miles
Doan Willard C. 1897 19** ** uncut?
Doan Marjorie R. 1898 19** ** uncut?
Cooney J. Arthur 1905 1934
Doan Bert L. 1882 1959
Doan Myrtle A. 1885 1954 w/of Bert
Doan Charles H. 1879 1946
Doan Maude E. 1883 1962 w/of Charles
Doan Jacob B. 1807 1882
Doan Sally Ann 1812 1898 w/of Jacob
Doan Sylvester C. 1840 1923
Doan Polly B. 1842 1914 w/of Sylvester
Kizer C.R. 1863 1916 Father
Kizer Alice 1866 1933 Mother
Kizer Anna Dec. 8, 1891 Oct. 24, 1899 d/of C. & A.
Clemens Harold A. 1899 1961
Clemens Grace M. 1896 ** ** uncut
Baird Nathan May 3, 1836 Oct. 20, 1909
Baird Catherine Apr. 13, 1835 Apr. 24, 1871 w/of Nathan
Baird Eliza E. May 19, 1843 Nov. 13, 1910 w/of Nathan
Owlett Fannie M. Feb. 21, 1861 May 14, 1881
Stratton Nettie J. Baird May 9, 1873 Nov. 21, 1911 Nee: Baird
Butler M.S. Dec. 30, 1839 Aug. 2, 1898 Father
Butler Jane July 2, 1841 Mar. 27, 1903 Mother
Butler Jud A. 1870 1953
Butler Alice T. 1872 1942
Butler * Jan. 29, 1913 *Infant dau. of J.A. & Alice Butler
Butler Ralph E. 1902 1926
Butler Merlin R. 1916 1940
Ladd Laurence E. 1900 1971 W.W.1 - marker & flag
Butler Esther B. 1919 * * Uncut?
Ladd Sharon K. 1947 *(is she the dau of L. & E. ?)
Churchill Lena May Mar 10, 1882 Apr. 10, 1882 d/of C.B. & E.
Butler Larry D. June 18, 1932 Jul. 4, 1932
Butler Esther Dawn Jan. 13, 1937 Sept. 19, 1938
Wetmore May. * * *No dates --- " Baby May d/of B. & L."
Butler Waldo S. 1894 19** ** Uncut?
Butler Mabel Treat 1894 1922 Nee: Treat -- w/of W.S.
Butler Florence A. 1925 * * Uncut?
Sutton Emma M. Sept. 21, 1850 Nov. 19, 1896 w/of E.D. Sutton
Butler Elantson 1851 1925
Butler Franklin 1854 1947
Butler Polly 1855 1938 w/of Franklin
Butler John N. 1870 1892
Butler Norris 1839 1913
Ream Betsey Ann *1846 1922 *(says Ream, but insinuates that she is the wife of Norris Butler)put in as written.
Ream Nellie L. *1865 1935 *insinuates that she is a Butler - sic.
Butler Seldon July 15, 1806 Oct. 19, 1888 Father
Butler Lucretia May 30, 1813 Jan. 11, 1886 Mother w/of Selden
Butler Salem J. 1848 1927
Butler Mary E. 1851 1918 w/of Salem
Butler Milton J. 1873 1892 s/of Salem & Mary
Butler Milton S. May 19, 1867 aged 29-2-11 ** Believe this & the next to be the one and the same.
Butler S.M. Mar. 8, 1838 May 19, 1867
Doan Herman E. 1878 1943
Doan Frances W. 1881 1943
Kizer Abijah May 29, 1837 Oct. 6, 1901 Co. H. 207th Pa Vol. - Flag & marker
** ** Note say's that the following the typist left out- should be between DeFrance Odle & Bertl L. Doan. 
Butler Allen 1798 1868
Butler Dimmis H. 1809 1887 w/Allen Butler
Butler Aaron A. 1838 1916
Butler Caroline L. 1849 1917 w/Aaron A.
Butler Freddie Oct. 13, 1870 Oct. 2, 1881 s/of A.A. & C.L.
Farnsworth Willie A. 1871 1943 Father
Farnsworth Flora E. 1879 19** Mother
Farnsworth * Nov. 3, 1908 * Infant son of W.A. & F.E. Farnsworth
Butler Coral M. 1876 1940
Butler Martha E. 1878 19** ** Uncut?
Odle Blanche 1887 1903
Joyce Tip Box -- December 2007 -
If you are not navigating this Tri-Counties Site via the left and right sidebars of the Current What's New page you are doing yourself a disservice. You can get to any place on the site easily by making yourself familiar with these subject and place topics. Try them all to be as familiar with the site's 16,000 plus pages as you can. Stop groping in the dark and take the lighted path. That's also the only way you'll find the search engines for the site or have access to the necessary messages I may leave for you. Make it easy on yourself. 

Published On Tri-Counties Site On 10/10/1997
By Joyce M. Tice
Email: JoyceTice@aol.com

You are the  visitor since the counter was installed on October 10, 1997. 
Page Relocated & Counter reset  02 NOV 2000 & 23 AUG 2003